13 Underrated Thrillers to Read This Fall

  • Copy By:
    Megan Stroup Tristao

In the event you couldn’t inform, we love thrillers right here at The Everygirl. Thrillers to maintain you up all evening? Examine. Thrillers to have fun Halloween? Examine. Thrillers simply because we love them? Examine. However as a lot as I really like to twist up with a Gillian Flynn, Ruth Ware, or Jane Harper novel, typically I would like one thing a little completely different—one thing I haven’t seen splashed over each booklist and bookstore show desk with the promise “You’ll NEVER see this twist coming!” or the oft-cited (and oft-controversial) “The subsequent Gone Woman!”

With that in thoughts, this record contains psychological thrillers, detective tales, page-turning horror, and different suspenseful books that won’t have made it onto your nightstand but. (And for those who’ve learn all of them, please go away extra underrated suggestions within the feedback! We’re all the time trying to diversify my thriller food regimen.)


Sheena Kamal

The Misplaced Ones

A number of years in the past, I spotted I used to be studying diversely in most genres besides one: mysteries and thrillers. These all appeared to be written by white girls, primarily from the U.S. or U.Ok. So, I wrote into one in every of my favourite bookish podcasts (“Get Booked!” from E book Riot) to request thrillers by Girls of Colour, and “The Misplaced Ones” by Caribbean-born writer Sheena Kamal was their prime suggestion. Set in Canada, the e-book’s protagonist is Nora Watts, who’s requested to assist discover a lacking teenage woman—Nora’s daughter, who was adopted 15 years in the past. I particularly appreciated the working commentary on the therapy of Indigenous folks in Canada all through the story. And if you would like extra Nora Watts in your life, Kamal has since revealed two extra novels and a novella within the sequence.

Nic Joseph

Boy, 9, Lacking

I’ve learn all three of Nic Joseph’s thrillers to date, however her debut novel remains to be my favourite. “Boy, 9, Lacking” begins when a 9-year-old boy dies throughout a cocktail party within the early 1990s. The one witness is one other younger boy who refuses to discuss the incident. Greater than 20 years later, one other 9-year-old boy goes lacking, and there’s loads of purpose to suspect the 2 tragedies are associated.

Jennifer Hillier

Jar of Hearts

Wicked. Grisly. Pulse-pounding. These are just some phrases reviewers have used to explain this novel by Canadian-born writer Jennifer Hillier. Set within the Pacific Northwest, the e-book encompasses a younger feminine govt with a darkish secret, an escaped serial killer, and the proper quantity of flashbacks to maintain you intrigued with out turning into annoyed. To be truthful, nearly everybody I do know who has learn this award-winning thriller has beloved it, however I simply don’t assume sufficient folks have learn it! And for those who like Hillier’s writing, she has 5 different thrillers so that you can devour.

Elisabeth Thomas

Catherine Home

This debut novel strongly jogged my memory of two of my 2020 faves to this point—“Lakewood” and “When No One is Watching”—although way more atmospheric and quieter in tone. On this Gothic novel, Ines earns a spot at an elite boarding faculty, which had made headlines years earlier than for questionable experiments. In the event you missed that back-to-school feeling this yr, “Catherine Home” might scratch your itch. (So long as your thought of a back-to-school learn is crammed with creepy, secretive cult vibes on a crumbling, remoted campus.)

Nayomi Munaweera

What Lies Between Us

This novel by a prize-winning Sri Lankan author isn’t the heart-pounding, twisty storyline typical of standard books within the style, but it surely’s undoubtedly price a learn. Extra of a literary gradual burn, the quiet suspense on this novel builds from the primary chapter, when the narrator confesses from her cell that she has “accomplished the unthinkable.” What follows is a narrative of a childhood in Sri Lanka, an immigration to the USA, and a fancy and delightful portrait of a wedding… however we all know all the time it gained’t finish properly.

Cecilia Ekbäck

Wolf Winter

I learn “Wolf Winter” over two days again in 2016 and I nonetheless discover myself serious about it. I clearly haven’t accomplished a ok job evangelizing about this e-book, although, as a result of I simply checked my Goodreads and… a whopping zero of my pals have learn this e-book. (So please indulge me!) This atmospheric novel that includes a homesteading household throughout a brutal winter in 18th-century Scandinavia marries elegant writing with compulsive readability, making it one other glorious selection for literary fiction followers who’re craving suspense (or thriller followers who respect nice writing).

Tananarive Due

The Good Home

I actually can’t consider Tananarive Due isn’t proper up there on each horror studying record subsequent to Stephen King and Shirley Jackson. (Effectively, I suppose I can as a result of #publishingsowhite, however I fervently want it weren’t so.) I listened to this audiobook a number of years in the past to arrange for Halloween, and woman, was I spooked! This supernatural story encompasses a Black lady who strikes into an inherited home with a haunted historical past in a predominantly white city in Washington. “The Good Home” is a little bit of a doorstopper (clocking in round 500 pages), however Robin Miles narrates the audiobook exquisitely, so I undoubtedly advocate going the audio route if lengthy books intimidate you. (Or for those who merely get pleasure from an excellent audiobook!)

Hye-Younger Pyun, Translated By: Sora Kim-Russell

The Gap

In the event you like quiet, tense psychological horror movies, I feel this e-book is for you! Brief and darkish, “The Gap” was a bestseller within the writer’s house nation of South Korea. It begins with a terrifying premise: A person awakens in a hospital to find the accident that paralyzed him additionally killed his spouse. As his mother-in-law assumes management of his care, the horror of the concept of being stripped of all bodily autonomy is compounded with secrets and techniques from his previous and the reality about what occurred the evening of the accident.

Tiffany D. Jackson


We’re followers of Tiffany D. Jackson over right here at The Everygirl; we’ve really useful her mature younger grownup books “Monday’s Not Coming” and “Grown” earlier than, however don’t overlook her 2017 debut novel, “Allegedly.” The novel begins with an (fictional) excerpt from “Infants Killing Infants: Profiles of Preteen and Teen Murderers,” so be ready for a disturbing and twisted storyline.

Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Untamed Shore

Silvia Moreno-Garcia is a grasp of page-turning coming-of-age novels, so once I belatedly discovered she had launched a e-book between final yr’s incredible “Gods of Jade of Shadow” and this yr’s summer season hit “Mexican Gothic,” I instantly snatched it up. Billed as Moreno-Garcia’s “first thriller” by the writer, “Untamed Shore” encompasses a younger lady in a small Baja California city throughout the late 1970s whose summer season takes a darkish flip after she turns into entangled with three American vacationers.

Louisa Luna

Two Women Down

I nearly made it by means of this whole record with out together with a e-book with “woman” within the title… however I promise, this one deserves a spot! After two younger sisters go lacking from a car parking zone in rural Pennsylvania, a non-public investigator from California groups up with a disgraced former officer from the native police pressure in a race to seek out the ladies. A second e-book that includes the investigative duo launched earlier this yr (“The Janes”), and I look ahead to inhaling that one as properly.

Attica Locke

The Slicing Season

Attica Locke isn’t an unknown writer by any means; she has obtained crucial approval for her thriller tales, and we’ve raved about her earlier than on The Everygirl, however I nonetheless really feel like far more folks have to learn and respect her, therefore her inclusion on this record. “The Slicing Season” is Locke’s solely standalone thriller to this point, so it’s a terrific first novel for anybody trying to dip into her writing. The first thriller on this novel facilities round a useless migrant employee discovered buried on a plantation-turned-tourist-attraction within the up to date American South, but it surely rapidly turns into obvious the modern-day crime could also be related to sordid secrets and techniques within the plantation’s previous.

Ivy Pochoda

These Girls

For one more crime novel with notable crucial acclaim however not sufficient standard appreciation (IMHO), I current “These Girls.” Within the late 1990s, a serial killer hunted intercourse staff on the streets of South Los Angeles earlier than the murders abruptly stopped. Fifteen years later, the killings start once more. By the distinctive narrative construction of the story, Pochoda voices the experiences of assorted girls residing in the neighborhood as they search solutions and justice for the useless.


What are a few of your favourite underrated thrillers? Tell us within the feedback!

Your Header Sidebar area is currently empty. Hurry up and add some widgets.